Playstation 3 Vs Xbox 360

Since I have have owned at one point of other all the current game systems, I've had people ask me which is the ideal one. The age old question, since Atari Vs Intellivision, has always been "Which has the better graphics"? That was the big question during the 90's with the Sega Vs Nintendo war. Unfortunately, that question no longer applies to today's serious systems. Both PS3 and 360's graphics are unbelievable, especially in HD. This analysis is not to compare specs and such, but to see the myriad of uses these systems have to offer, each in its own unique way.

XBOX 360

Gaming: The older of the 2 systems (launched 11/22/2005), the 360 is the workhorse of the game industry. It is THE system that is the standard when it comes to gaming. Almost all major titles that get released are released on, with the exception of the exclusives from Sony (like Uncharted) and Nintendo (Zelda, Mario, etc). It's own exclusives are some of the industry's best, such as the Gears of War and Mass Effect series. Because it is so big, it can have a big influence on game developers, such as getting them to release games and downloadable content (DLC) weeks or months before any other system. Controllers feel natural in the hands and the button layout is comfortable, especially in a big guy's hands like myself. Also a negative is the startup cost. The barebones systems ($199) have no Hard Drive, so that's about $60+ for the proprietary ones. The standard systems need a wireless adapter ($70) to get online to access the network, play online, etc. THEN you have to pay $50 a year to be able to ACCESS that network to play online, stream movies, etc. Then, you have to buy batteries for the controllers or buy the rechargeable packs. Thus, if you are buying a new setup, you are looking at around $400 for the barebones, not including a good game, extra controller, HDMI cable. The newest model has an HDD and wireless adapter already built in for $299.

Entertainment: The Xbox 360 can be hooked up to an HDTV through component, composite or HDMI cables. The 360 is made by Microsoft, so it's no surprise that compatibility between it and the computer is great. You can stream pictures, music and movies from your computer to the 360 to watch on your TV. Within the dashboard, you can access apps like Facebook, Last FM, Zune and most importantly, Netflix. The ability to stream Netflix and watch whatever you have in your queue is what sets makes this system a viable entertainment component. While you can do the same with the PS3, that system requires you to insert a disc to access your queue and movies. The only problem I have with this is that some movies are not available in HD. The other problem I have is that the 360 has limited codec compatibility while streaming through the Windows Media Player server, meaning that while it can play its Windows Media Audio/Video (WMA and WMV) just fine, other basic video and audio file types (like AVI, MPEG, etc) are iffy. And needless to say, WMV video is not really all that high def.

Overall: A must-have system when it comes to gaming and streaming TV shows and movies through Netflix.



Unfortunately, the 360 has been plagued with hardware problems, resulting in the dreaded Red Ring of Death. These problems seem to have been addressed in the newly revamped "Slim" model.

Rating: Gaming 10/10. Entertainment 7/10.

Playstation 3

Released 11/11/2006, Sony's PS3 had high expectations when it launched. Initial cost was $499 for the 20Gb and $599 for the 60GB kept the system out of reach for normal consumers. Unfortunately, when supply finally could keep up with demand, people saw that it's game library was a bit uninspired and held off. Thus PS3 has been playing catch up with the 360, now catching up in sales since the prices have dropped.

Gaming: While the PS3 can hold its own in the gaming department, it does not have the support 360 does. PS3 will get DLC or games weeks or months after Xbox does. An example is the game Overlord. It had been out on 360 for so long, it was already just $19.99. When it finally came out for PS3, they charged the full $59.99. Exclusives such as the Uncharted and God of War series are fantastic, but not enough to carry the system like Halo, Gears of War, Mass Effect does for the 360. The controller is the same size and shape as it has been from PSX and PS2.

Entertainment: Here is where the PS3 really shines. It was one of the first Blu-Ray 2.0 players on the market. It is much more tolerant of other file types (AVI, MPEG, etc). With some excellent server software, it can stream music, pictures and full HD Blu-Ray movie files (such as M2TS and MKV). Now, getting a full-fledged Blu-Ray player with great games available for $299 is a fantastic deal. The one negative I see with this is the fact that you have to insert a disc to access the Netlix service, but will be fixed this fall. The ability to watch/listen your files that you have saved on your computer in another room, and not use up space on the PS3 hard drive, is the deal-sealer for me.

Overall: While kind of mild on the serious gaming side, as an all-around entertainment system, this is the one to get. It's HD capabilities are the finest around, beating out even dedicated Blu-Ray players with its DLNA compliant streaming capabilities.

Rating: Gaming: 8/10. Entertainment: 10/10

OUTCOME: Should be obvious by now. If you play games and watch a lot of movies and love that theater experience, the PS3 is for you. If you are a hard-core gamer that does marathon sessions of Halo, COD, etc, and watch regular DVD's and standard def movies on Netflix, the 360 is the standard.

Note: The Wii was not included in this analysis because it does neither gaming or entertainment seriously enough to be considered. It is not HD, nor does it have hardcore multiplayer games. It is a "casual" gaming system, and thus it is very good at what it does.

EDIT: My friend Rod from work asked about the differences about online. Here are the facts:

1. Xbox requires you to have a monthly membership to Xbox Live (XBL) in order to access ANY online feature, and some level of memberships can get more than others. Silver membership is FREE and it lets you access everything in the marketplace and buy add-ons (DLC) for your games, BUT YOU CANNOT PLAY ONLINE MULTIPLAYER. For that, you need a GOLD membership, which costs $7.99 a month or $49.99 a year.
2. Playstation has all access to its Network, to download demos, buy games, rent movies AND play online for FREE. It now offers a paid subscription called Playstation Network Plus (PSN+) for $49.99 a year. With that, you get to try full games before you buy, discounts and invitations to beta trials. In my opinion, that really isn't worth the cost for such small benefits, especially when the meat and potatoes (streaming movies and playing online) are FREE, compared to having to pay for the same thing on XBL.